Final Report on Principal Hill is Published -Falls Short of Finding All Misconduct.

The other day I finally received the public version of thefinal report that found Principal Linda Hill of Berta Dreyfus IS 49 guilty of financial misconduct. Besides it being heavily redacted, it fell extremely short of finding all the malfeasance that took place at this troubled school. See the email I sent below to an eclectic range of people. Most of them have the power and authority toto do something. From politicians, auditors and attorney generals to DOE’s upper echelon, all have been made aware.Let’s see if Principal Hill will get away with it, a large bonus and residual pension inclusive of unearned money.

From: Francesco Portelos <>
Date: Mon, Jun 1, 2015 at 4:23 PM
Subject: Incomplete Investigation OSI Case # 12-533
To: Vargo Jaclyn <>, Courtenaye Jackson-Chase <>, Faria Carmen <>,,
Cc:,, “Mark G. Peters” <>,, “Regina A. Loughran” <>,, Susan Edelman <>,, Ben Chapman <>, Jim Dwyer <>, Diane Lore <>,, Panel for Educational Policy <>, Gibson Dorita <>,, Feijoo Laura <>,,, Nicole Malliotakis <>,, NYSED Commissioner <>,, Dan Rosenblum <>,,, Frank Patone <>,,,,, Jaenicke Gregory <>,,,, Senator Andrew Lanza <>, RSinger4 <>,, Greenfield Robin <>

Good morning,

This month Intermediate School 49 Principal Linda Hill will be retiring and start collecting her pension. Her pension is calculated by taking the average of her salary inclusive of her overtime accrued. In addition, she will be collecting a substantial retro pay bonus of approximately $70,000 because of the agreement with the CSA union and NYC.
Principal Hill stole. She stole from me, she stole from all of you and most importantly she stole from our students and the community. The attached, and heavily redacted, final report falls very, very short of finding all the malfeasance that took place at the troubled middle school in Staten Island. I am no investigator, but comparing the information in the final report with a simple spreadsheet I created, from records I obtained, shows a great deficiency in the investigation.

For example:
– Investigator Lawrence Scott found that Principal Hill engaged in “double dipping” on 14 occasions, while in fact she engaged in this behavior at least 22 times.
– The report does not indicate that Principal Linda Hill was paid while out sick on November 2011, when in fact she was.
– The report does not indicate that instead of using a digital time clock, located just several feet from her office, Principal Linda Hill hand wrote her time in and out over 118 times.
-The investigation report also did not indicate the issue with the 3 hr time restraint for the program billed. Even though the Achieve Now Academy program required a 3 hr limit per day, Principal Linda Hill far exceeded that including in June 2011 when she was actually at a dinner having drinks and yes billed the tax payer.
-It also didn’t include the days she was billing the program on Saturdays and even after the last day of school.

What is worse is the high level of corruption and cover up by many upper level employees of the NYC Department of Education and investigative offices. From the chancellor’s office to the legal department.

I’ll contact each office copied here separately in an effort to bring justice. Principal Hill should be charged pursuant to NYS Ed Law 3020-a. She was already found guilty of larceny, defrauding the government and misdemeanor, yet still runs the school today.

Francesco A. Portelos
UFT Solidarity


Below is the spreadsheet I put together while in exile for even raising this concern. Notice the questionable billing. Much of it was not mentioned. The program was from Tuesday to Thursday for only three hours.

Principal Linda Hill Questionable Overtime_Page_1 Principal Linda Hill Questionable Overtime_Page_2

Here is thefinal public version of thereport. Among many other things, noticehow long this 900 day investigation took. Reported by me on January 26, 2012, then not mentioned here, but Principal Hill’s time cards were collected in March 2012, I was coincidentally removed from the school right after and then not questioned for over a year despite this website having posted all evidence needed in June 2012.

F10,861-for release-OSI rept_Page_1 F10,861-for release-OSI rept_Page_2 F10,861-for release-OSI rept_Page_4 F10,861-for release-OSI rept_Page_5 F10,861-for release-OSI rept_Page_6 F10,861-for release-OSI rept_Page_7 F10,861-for release-OSI rept_Page_8 F10,861-for release-OSI rept_Page_9

In the end she had to pay $801 in restitution. That’s it. The questionable money will continue to be deposited into her account as her pension.

Leave a comment below. Should we move forward with a rally before June is over No one steals from our students and community gets away with it!


Principal Linda Hill

See also Faria principal pal gets free pass after ripping off taxpayers

And Warrengate


About Francesco Portelos

Parent and Educator fighting for the student and the teacher.
Bookmark the permalink.


  1. Have you shared this info with Byran Glass How is it possible that she did this over a three plus year time spand and she did not get fired I will need to use this info if you don’t mind……

  2. I understand that Robert Colon must be chief CSA rep assigned to principals who get their hands stuck in the cookie jar. He has “helped” many principals avoid a 3020a hearing and facing criminal charges. See:

  3. WOW what a mess! I would have moved on in a different province. I am from Canada. I have worked in union and non union. And union seems to be the most toxic, fear based and detached. I am an ironworker welder. fabricator. with shop skills. in a union I can only weld! it is too rigid. you cannot grow in your job. they stifle you only in the union itself can you grow more. think about that.. Not your job! but politics! no thanks. I no longer will employ myself in a union setting. I am happy and free again. I could have fought tooth and nail and still nothing would have happened.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.